Here’s a question I’d like every board to ask, and almost none do. What state was the CEO in when they made that decision?
I mean the person. How they’d slept, what they were carrying into the room, how much else was fighting for their attention that morning.
We audit the numbers every quarter. We stress-test the strategy, the balance sheet, the supply chain and the cyber defenses. Then we hand the biggest decisions in the company to one human nervous system and assume it shows up the same way every morning.
It doesn’t. Mine doesn’t. Yours doesn’t either.
I’ve put it this way before: "If the CEO has a bad night’s sleep, or a fight with their spouse before work, it impacts input seeking behavior and decision-making quality for the rest of the day." I stand by every word of that, and I’d go further. Most executives treat the quality of their own judgment as something they own outright, earned on the way up like the title. In my experience it behaves much more like the weather. And nobody’s keeping a record of it.
Two of my axioms sit underneath this. Input seeking behavior is a skill. Decision making quality is an art. Skills can be trained, and they can also slip. Art depends heavily on the state of the artist. Being good at either last year guarantees nothing about this morning.
Think about what input seeking looks like on a bad day. You ask fewer questions. You take the first credible answer. You hear your CFO’s concern as an obstacle. You go quiet in the meeting where you should have pushed, or you push in the meeting where you should have listened.
From the inside, all of that feels like being decisive.
That’s the trap. Under pressure, the mind gets very good at defending a decision and much worse at testing it. It happens to good leaders as often as bad ones.
So you can’t fix it with willpower. The instrument you’d use to check your judgment is the same instrument that’s compromised.
This matters more at the top than anywhere else in the building. "A CEO is the most leveraged human system in the organization." A frontline manager’s bad morning costs one team a bad morning. A CEO’s bad morning can shape an acquisition, a restructuring or a senior hire. It can set the tone of a town hall that thousands of people will remember for years. And it travels. "Culture does not start with policies. Culture starts at the top. More precisely, with the CEO’s nervous system."
This is where I think governance has a blind spot. "Boards often talk about ‘tone at the top’ while failing to operationalize it." A board will ask for a risk register forty lines long, and not one of those lines will be about the condition of the person signing off on the other thirty-nine.
Hard decisions rarely wait for a good night’s sleep. CEOs will make plenty of calls tired, angry or worried, and that’s the job. My argument is narrower. State should be part of how decisions get made at the top, deliberately and out loud.
Before a decision of real consequence, add a second question to the first. You already ask what you know. Ask what condition you’re in to weigh it.
If the honest answer is poor, keep going, carefully. Slow down where you can. Widen your input where you can’t. And let someone test your reasoning before the market does.
That last part is the hardest, because most executives have nobody placed to do it. Your team wants your approval. Your board sees you a few times a year. Your peers are competitors or friends, and neither tends to say, "I think you’re deciding this on four hours’ sleep."
That’s a large part of why I coach at this level. My job in the room is to test your thinking, and I’ve got nothing to gain from agreeing with you.
If you’d like to talk about what that would look like for you, the next step is a conversation.
Book a call: https://www.corrieblock.com/connect/